Chapter 4
Omissions
You don't sleep after the conversation. You lie on top of the covers with the phone on your chest, rereading her texts until the screen dims, then tapping it awake to read them again.
It's strange, what a few lines on a screen can do. In person she's all edges. At two in the morning, typing in the dark forty-one floors above the city, she sounded like someone who'd been shot at and didn't have anyone to tell.
Around five you give up, shower and shave. There's a bruise on your shoulder the size of a fist, going purple at the edges. You look at it in the mirror for a long time.
You could have died for her last night. You'd met her twice.
Doyle likes Lucky's on Halsted because nobody under sixty eats there and the waitress calls everyone hon. He's already in the back booth when you arrive, working through a plate of eggs and corned beef hash, Tessa beside him with black coffee and her laptop open.
"There's my rising star," Doyle says. "Sit. Eat. You look like hell."
"Couldn't sleep."
"First week undercover, nobody sleeps." He points his fork at you. "Talk."
So you talk. You tell him about the regulars, the aldermen, the three tables of men who watch the door. You tell him about Tullio and the Negronis and the house rule about family tabs. You tell him Serafina made you an offer: keep the cover, keep reporting, help her when she asks.
"Help her with what?" Doyle asks.
"She thinks someone in the family wants her out of the way before Aldo names a successor."
"Ha." He wipes his mouth. "Welcome to the Vitales. Somebody always wants somebody out of the way. That's Tuesday."
You wait for the moment to tell him about the alley.
Six shots. A dark sedan. Your body over hers on the asphalt.
It's the most important thing that's happened since you walked in the door. Protocol says you should have called it in from the curb last night. Protocol says it goes in your report today, in detail, with times.
Doyle is looking at you. Friendly. Patient.
"Anything else?" he says.
Somewhere behind your ribs, something small and stubborn closes like a fist. You don't know yet who told Serafina your credential number. Forty people had access. Doyle is one of them.
"No," you say. "Quiet night."
Tessa's eyes come up from her laptop and rest on your face for exactly one second.
Then Doyle grins and pushes the plate of toast toward you. "Quiet's good. Quiet means she trusts you. Keep it quiet. Keep her talking."
Tessa catches you in the parking lot.
"You have a bruise on your neck," she says.
You touch your collar. It's the edge of the shoulder bruise, crawling up.
"I slipped. Wet floor behind the bar."
"Uh huh." Tessa hugs her laptop to her chest. "I worked the Calumet task force with you for two years, Ethan. You don't slip. You also lie with your left eyebrow."
"I don't have a left eyebrow thing."
"You absolutely have a left eyebrow thing." She glances back at the diner window, where Doyle is paying the check and joking with the waitress. Her voice drops. "I'm not asking. Okay? I'm not asking. I'm just saying, if you ever need someone to pull something quietly, I'm good at quiet."
You look at her. Tired eyes, almond dust on her sleeve. The only person at the Bureau who argued to pull you out.
"I know," you say. "Thanks."
Velluto is closed on Mondays, so on Tuesday you come in at three to find a small square envelope on the bar with your name on it.
Heavy paper. No stamp. Inside, a card in the same handwriting as the napkin.
Sunday. One o'clock. 1140 Ashland Avenue, River Forest. My father would like to meet you. Bring nothing. He'll be insulted by wine and hurt by flowers. S.
You read it three times.
Val is leaning on the end of the bar, eating olives out of the garnish tray, which Augie has told you is a crime punishable by death.
"Did you know about this?" you ask her.
"I delivered it."
"Why does her father want to meet a bartender?"
Val chews an olive slowly. "Because his daughter told him on Saturday morning that somebody shot at her Friday night, and that the new bartender put himself between her and six bullets without being asked." She spits the pit into a napkin. "Aldo Vitale has been waiting twenty-eight years for someone to do that besides me."
"She told him."
"She always tells him. Before anyone else can." Val studies you with those flat, unblinking eyes. "I don't like you, Ethan."
"So I hear."
"I don't like how you move. I don't like that you were looking at the alley mouth before the car turned in. Bartenders look at their phones." She pushes off the bar. "But you covered her. So I'll be civil until I find out what you are."
"And then?"
"And then I'll decide."
Serafina comes in at nine that night and doesn't sit at your bar.
She works the room the way she always does, all soft voice and steady eyes. But twice, while you're shaking a drink, you look up and find her watching you from across the floor. Both times she doesn't look away. Both times you do.
At midnight, passing behind you to the kitchen, she stops long enough to say, without turning her head, "You got my invitation."
"Your father wants to meet me."
"My father wants to look at you." She adjusts a stack of menus that doesn't need adjusting. "He's old-fashioned. If someone bleeds for his family, he likes to shake their hand."
"I didn't bleed."
"I did." She turns her palm up. The scrape has healed to a thin pink line. "That counts."
"What do I call him?"
"Mr. Vitale, until he tells you otherwise. Don't call him Don. Only television calls him that." A pause. "Don't talk about money, don't talk about the Brancatos, and if my cousin starts something, let him."
"And you?"
"What about me?"
"What am I, at this dinner? Your bartender?"
Serafina finally looks at you. Something in her face is almost shy, and she seems to hate it.
"My friend," she says. "You're my friend, Ethan. I don't bring friends home. So try not to make a liar out of me."
She walks into the kitchen before you can answer.
Sunday comes cold and bright.
River Forest is a different planet from Bridgeport. Wide lawns, old oaks letting go of the last of their leaves, stone houses set far back from the street. The Vitale house is gray limestone with green shutters and a long glass greenhouse glowing along one side like a lantern. Two men in dark coats stand near the garage, smoking, watching your car.
You park on the street. You leave the revolver in your glovebox. That feels like the worst decision of your life and the only possible one.
You walk up the path. The door is oak, carved with lemons and vines. Before you can knock, it opens.
The man standing there is sixty-one and looks older. Silver hair combed straight back. A cardigan the color of olive oil over a white shirt. Reading glasses folded in the pocket. He's shorter than you expected and broader, with hands like a stonemason's, and Serafina's eyes, exactly, set in a softer, sadder face.
Aldo Vitale looks at you for a long moment, the way you'd look at a used car.
Then he holds out one of those big hands.
"So," he says, gripping yours hard enough to hurt. "You're the one."
"Mr. Vitale."
"You put your body on my daughter in an alley." He doesn't let go. "Before you come into my house and eat my food, you're going to tell me something, and you're going to tell me the truth."
Behind him, at the end of the long hallway, you see Serafina step out of a doorway and freeze.
Aldo's grip tightens.
"What do you want," he says quietly, "from my daughter?"
Your love interest is about to text you.
Start free to answer at the cliffhanger. Your replies change what happens next, and your name goes into the story.
Characters are AI-generated and fictional. 18+ only.