Chapter 4

Full Sentences

You fall asleep at some point after two with your phone on your chest, and when you wake up, the conversation is still there on the screen.

You read it again before you're fully awake. Full sentences. Capital letters. Periods at the end of everything, even Goodnight. You didn't know people still texted like that. You didn't know a man could make a period sound like a hand on the small of your back.

You lie there for a minute longer than you should, looking at the ceiling.

Then you hear the drill.


By eight there are three men on your father's property and none of them are Hayes.

Darius Odell introduces himself at the kitchen door: six-three, shaved head, a dark gray suit in ninety-degree heat, and a smile that would sell toothpaste on three continents. He holds out a hand.

"Ma'am. I hear I need to be approved."

"Who told you that?"

"The boss. He said, and I'm quoting, 'She'll decide.' Then he went outside and stared at a fence post for ten minutes." Darius's smile widens. "I've known him eleven years. I've never seen him lose a staring contest with a fence post."

You like him immediately. You try not to show it. "Approved. Provisionally."

"I'll take provisionally."

Hayes is on a ladder at the corner of the guest house, mounting a camera under the eave. He's in a faded Navy T-shirt that has been washed into softness, and when he reaches up the hem rides above his belt. You look at the coffee in your hand with tremendous focus.

"He's put in six cameras since dawn," Darius says beside you, conversationally. "Dock, gate, pool, both doors, and one pointing straight at the water. Not one inside the house."

"Why not inside?"

Darius gives you a look you can't read. "He said your father's house is your home, not a job site. He said nobody's watching you where you live." He drains his own coffee. "Also, he said if I told you that, he'd make me run the bridge at noon. So you didn't hear it from me."


Detective Wilder comes at ten and bags the card and rose in two separate evidence envelopes. She's in her late thirties, sharp-boned and dark-haired, with the kind of face that would get her cast as a detective on television and the kind of temper that would get her fired from the show.

"We pulled the Hasell Street footage," she says. "Somebody in a ball cap and a rain jacket walks up to your car at 9:40, leaves the rose, walks away toward Meeting. Six feet, give or take. Face never turns to the camera."

"It's him," you say.

"Probably." She glances at Hayes, who's leaning in the doorway with his arms crossed. "Your guy's people pulled it before mine did."

"He's not my guy," you say at the same moment Hayes says, "I'm not her guy."

Wilder looks between you. One eyebrow goes up a millimeter. "Okay," she says, in a voice that means the opposite.


At lunch you find the glasses.

They're on the dining table next to his laptop, black frames, folded, and you pick them up and put them on and look at your reflection in the window. Way too strong. The harbor swims.

"Put those down."

You turn. He's in the doorway again. He is always in a doorway, you're beginning to notice, like a man who wants to be in a room and won't let himself.

"These are cute," you tell him.

"They're not cute. They're medical equipment."

"How long have you needed them?"

"Two years." He crosses the room and holds out his hand, palm up. "Give."

"Say please."

"Please give me my glasses, Ava, before I have to tell your father I stopped protecting you because you stole my eyes."

You laugh, and you hand them over, and his fingers close around yours for a second around the frames. Warm. Rough-skinned. He takes the glasses and doesn't let go of your hand immediately, and then he does.

"I made sandwiches," you say, because somebody has to say something. "On the dock. Since I'm not allowed to go anywhere."

He hesitates. You can see him doing a calculation, and you can see him losing it.

"Okay," he says.


The dock runs sixty feet out over the marsh to a covered platform where your father keeps two rocking chairs and a cooler. The tide is out, the pluff mud shining and ticking in the heat, fiddler crabs waving their one big claw at nothing. You sit with your legs over the edge. He sits in a rocking chair, three feet back, like the distance is in a manual somewhere.

"Can I ask you something?" you say.

"You're going to anyway."

"Why'd you leave the Navy?"

He's quiet for so long you think he won't answer. Pelicans skim the channel in a line, wings almost touching the water.

"I was thirty-four," he says. "That's old, in that job. My knees were done, my shoulder was held together with screws, and I'd been to enough funerals." He turns his sandwich in his hands without eating it. "Your father had an idea for a company. He had the money and the clients. I had the training. He said, come home, build something that keeps people alive instead of the other thing. So I did."

"And then you split."

"Four years ago."

"Why?"

His face closes. Not angry. Just a door, swinging shut, quietly and completely. "That's between me and Warren."

You let it go. You don't know why. Maybe because of the way his thumb is pressing into the crust of the bread.

"Does anyone wait for you?" you ask instead. "At home. Sullivan's Island, right? Dad said you have a house there."

"A dog, once. He died." He finally takes a bite, chews, swallows. "I was married."

You turn around to look at him.

He's watching the water. "Annelise. She was an architect, actually. Worked for your father's development company, back before the security business. That's how I met him." A pause. "She died thirteen years ago. A car accident on 526. I was in Afghanistan."

"Hayes. I'm so sorry."

"It was a long time ago."

It doesn't look like a long time ago. It looks like it was this morning. He's sitting very upright in the rocking chair, and you have the strangest urge to put your hand on his knee, and you don't.

"I didn't know," you say.

"Most people don't. Your father knows." He stands abruptly, sandwich half-eaten. "Thank you for lunch. I need to call Darius."

You watch him walk back up the dock, shoulders squared, and you think: he's been standing in doorways for thirteen years.


At six, Detective Wilder calls again. You're in the kitchen. Hayes is across the island, and you put her on speaker.

"Pellham's attorney contacted us an hour ago," she says. "Colin claims he flew back to Boston yesterday afternoon to see his mother. He's got a boarding pass. His mother swears he was at her house in Brookline from six p.m. on, all night."

You stare at the phone. "That's impossible."

"His phone pinged off a tower in Brookline at nine-fifteen."

"Then he left his phone with her. Or she's lying."

"Maybe," Wilder says. "Or maybe the person who left that rose on your car isn't Colin Pellham at all."

The kitchen is so quiet you can hear the ice maker.

Across the island, Hayes has gone completely still. And when you look up at him, he's not looking at you. He's looking past you, out the window, at the dark line of the marsh, where anyone with a kayak could be at the end of the dock in five minutes.

Your love interest is about to text you.

Start free to answer at the cliffhanger. Your replies change what happens next, and your name goes into the story.

Characters are AI-generated and fictional.